Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bruce Guay's avatar

I’m constantly amazed at your ability as someone with your history and artistic sensibilities to share your innermost vulnerabilities so freely with us! 🎼💖💕

Expand full comment
Craig Nixon's avatar

Not a question, but I often find that I have (too) long responses to your incredible blog posts. The following is a Facebook post by Jennifer Litton Tidd that resonated with me, and I think will resonate with you, too. I've referred in the past to JH as one of my (our) greatest teachers, and while I realize that's mighty personal, a statement like this illustrates perfectly the "why" behind why I say that. :

I think I need to share this story because people need to understand how to appropriately interact with other humans, and how to be a better ally to disabled people.

I took my 15 year old autistic son to the pool for the first time this summer a couple weeks ago. He LOVES swimming. He was laughing out loud and smiling for the first two hours he was there. His joy was infectious and most were happy to see it. Two women in the pool though, were visibly annoyed, and decided it was time to shush him.

Q-man doesn’t do being shushed. And he self-advocated and said, “No no shhhh, Q is HAPPY!” We were at a pool with a big waterslide and lots of kids yelling, laughing and splashing. They decided to shush Q again for a second time about 15 minutes later. The first time they shushed him, I saw that he was standing up for himself, so I only moved closer, so he’d see I was there for backup, and that I approved of his self-advocacy. The second time they shushed him, I jumped in and walked over to them and told them to stop talking to my son. He’s being no louder than anyone else, that it was clear from their reactions and the situation, it wasn’t noise they objected to, but HIS sounds specifically. They apologized and then left him alone the remainder of the time we were there.

A woman approached me later in the locker-room to tell me she loves the sound of laughter of “special needs kids” and “intellectually challenged kids like your son.” Clearly, she was trying to be supportive, but let me be clear about several things. First off, his needs aren’t “special.” The need to be treated with respect, dignity, and support for his feelings aren’t special. These are needs any human has. Secondly, my son is not ID. Don’t assume to know someone’s diagnosis. He’s just a fellow human who was happy and laughing; that’s all this person knew, and all that needed to be said. There is nothing wrong at all with ID people, so it wasn’t an insult, just inaccurate. But I don’t need to justify his laughter or behavior by explaining to every stranger that he’s autistic. My son doesn’t exist to be everyone else’s teachable moment.

And thirdly, in my van on the way home, I thought more about it. It seems to me rather than whispering support in a locker-room, I’d have much preferred public support for my son. If I’d witnessed the same situation, I’d have responded to the shushing of a person like my son, “I love the sound of your laughter and happiness, thanks for sharing your joy.” Don’t other him. His autism in this situation wasn’t relevant. He also is impaired with his speaking communication, but his hearing is crystal clear. So talking about him in the third person rather than TO him about his laughter is erasure. Always assume competence first, please. He likes being talked to and complimented, JUST LIKE YOU.

He was just one of many happy people swimming at the pool; that’s all. His noises and physicality of being autistic aren’t typical of other 15 year olds, but they are perfectly natural, and how he expresses joy. I really don’t get why he can’t just be out in the world as a happy person laughing, and people can’t just see him as a fellow human having a good time.

Please do support someone being ganged up on, but please have the courage to do it in the situation without othering them further. Laughter is laughter, and all he was doing was laughing. Why should there be all this undercurrent and weirdness about a kid laughing and having fun at the pool?

I see it as yet another form of neurodivergent tone-policing. Not only do we have to express frustration or anger like NTs, but also, LAUGHTER? A person can’t just be elated and laugh how he wants without being policed?

Expand full comment
18 more comments...

No posts